DA Wolf Mafia #3 (Town Wins again!)

First topic message reminder :

























1. CrimsonOverlord
2. DanelerH
3. Lux
4. JC the shadow hunter
5. faervel
6. SilentKatana
7. hazmah
8. drunkion


To sign up, simply say "in".





Members of the winning faction will receive 1500 DP each. (You do not have to be alive at the end of the game to win unless you're the Wolf).

Last edited by Linda-Senpai on Wed Jun 15, 2016 11:28 pm; edited 12 times in total

SilentKatana wrote:

Again, apologies for not being so active atm, been a bit hectic on my end. I personally have no real clue as to whom to hit so far, as again, we do have no real evidence at this point. I could go out on an incredibly tenuous limb and say Crimson's constant asking for people to deny the validity of his claim is suspicious, but that is by far the most twisted logic I could come up with. It is most definitely not good logic, which is my point.

As such, I really would need to actually hear any evidence people would have on suspecting people, as I am totally in the dark as of right now, and do not want to make twisted logic branches...

I was thinking the same way, but I'm pretty sure now the doctor healed crims, knowing that crims is a valuable player and that mafia would want to hit him first. And I guess the wolf choosed to not kill anyone at Night 1, it's a logical move. 

JC the shadow hunter wrote:

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

No the others said to skip day and lynch the next day

I thought me,you,and lux decided that lynching tiday would be beneficial if we can get more input

And we did, we still have some time to figure out the cards. But we really need input from Hazmah and @Drunkion

Hazmah is either town or mafia, as in normal mafia. He doesnt have to give input in order for the kill to go through.
He aint the wolf i think due to him not giving any input at all and the night ended before deadline (aka inputs were given)

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

Hazmah is either town or mafia, as in normal mafia. He doesnt have to give input in order for the kill to go through.
He aint the wolf i think due to him not giving any input at all and the night ended before deadline (aka inputs were given)

as it is now, hazmah really is the most suspicious, especially since he never even commented yet lol, at least fark commented but he really needs to elaborate more on what he thinks >.<

JC the shadow hunter wrote:

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

Hazmah is either town or mafia, as in normal mafia. He doesnt have to give input in order for the kill to go through.
He aint the wolf i think due to him not giving any input at all and the night ended before deadline (aka inputs were given)

as it is now, hazmah really is the most suspicious, especially since he never even commented yet lol, at least fark commented but he really needs to elaborate more on what he thinks >.<

I'm actually giving a shot and saying he is the mafia. Look, there are not many mafia clues. Considering that only two players are mafia, and hazmah possibly being one, that leaves mafia really helpless and the battle continues between the town and the wolf. 

As for his role, I doubt he is godfather, if he's mafia, he's probably mafioso. 

Well hazmah is the safest blind shot? Idk he will probably be afk for a good while

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

Well hazmah is the safest blind shot? Idk he will probably be afk for a good while

If you ask me, he is indeed. I'll still wait for more opinions until I actually lynch him, maybe he will actually appear. 

Getting this eerie feeling hazmah is town though, but i guess even if we kill an afk town we dont lose much? Still wanna hear the rest

If we kill an afk Town, we effectively lose a meat-shield.  If some one decides to target Hazmah, that's fine, but it probably wont' happen.  On the other hand, it's still better to hit a Mafia.  As Faervel said, Lux and JC are the most suspicious if Hazmah is Town.  While we don't have anything else against JC, there is something else against Lux.  Earlier in the game, Lux said that xe was waiting for the Doctor to confirm that Crimson was healed.  Xe basically asked for the Doctor to reveal xemself, which is something the Doctor can no longer due since self-healing was removed.  I don't know if it was intentional or not, but it's more than what we have on Hazmah (which is just a blind guess).  Personally, I think I'm leaning a little more towards Lux as being Mafia.

It is rather suspicious that most want hazmah out and yes the doctor move was pretty out there,but here is a theory and again nothing personal just putting this out there.What if you are the godfather (again) and trying to defend your afk henchmen,hazmah? Quite bizarre i know,but it is something you have to take into account.

Or I could be the Gidfather and I'm trying to throw Lux under the bus to make myself less suspicious later.  There area multitude of theories and any of them could be right (except for these mentioned ones; I still hold my previous claim of being a regular Town).

*Godfather
I wish we were allowed to edit for typos.

faervel wrote:

Nooow...let's say we did that and he was
1.Mafia:I don't know where this puts Crim,Lux&Jc but I KNOW it doesn't put the other 3 in a great spot since they didn't exactly comment vs it(or comment at all..)
2.Town:Well,well,weellllll if he's town I'mma suspect the very 2 that keep insisting on this;Yep talking to you @Lux & @JC the shadow hunter ! I am not exactly a fan of you 2 trying to group yourself with the safest person atm and grouping the others aside.


Soo...I don't have anything vs you guys and as JC said we truly lack active players and are just trying to figure out stuff even though we have no official evidence.


But still....I wanna see if you're truly gonna go with this:


/Lynch Hazmah

But wasn't I the one who actually "gave a shot that Hazmah could be mafia"? How's that the safest option? You are actually trying to shift suspection to me and JC. And I know very well what you tried to do with your lynch. You are basically throwing a bait for me and JC to bite. 

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

 but i guess even if we kill an afk town we dont lose much? 

We lose a towm but we at least get rid of inactive player.

DanelerH wrote:

If we kill an afk Town, we effectively lose a meat-shield.  If some one decides to target Hazmah, that's fine, but it probably wont' happen.  On the other hand, it's still better to hit a Mafia.  As Faervel said, Lux and JC are the most suspicious if Hazmah is Town.  While we don't have anything else against JC, there is something else against Lux.  Earlier in the game, Lux said that xe was waiting for the Doctor to confirm that Crimson was healed.  Xe basically asked for the Doctor to reveal xemself, which is something the Doctor can no longer due since self-healing was removed.  I don't know if it was intentional or not, but it's more than what we have on Hazmah (which is just a blind guess).  Personally, I think I'm leaning a little more towards Lux as being Mafia.

I wouldn't be that stupid if I would be a mafia.

Yes but you did try to call out on the doc which is a bit suspicious.As for jc he is quite aloof so cant say for sure

It was a mistake, since I haven't read all of the replies.

Well we are going around in circles really. The group here says lynch hazmah (imo he is town). Farkion and kats still have no input on who to lynch,danny is trying to lynch you. Do you claim to be a regular town?

Correction:  I am merely suspicious of Lux.  I am not confident enough to try to lynch anyone yet.

Why are you so sure that Hazmah is town?

Because I don't think the killing order for me was discussed by just the godfather and then the kill went through without any plan. I think it was a consensual agreement. Also if he really is an afk mafia, then dan is godfather trying to protect him? This is the reasoning up to now.

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

Because I don't think the killing order for me was discussed by just the godfather and then the kill went through without any plan. I think it was a consensual agreement. Also if he really is an afk mafia, then dan is godfather trying to protect him? This is the reasoning up to now.

Fair enough. Possibly, but I'm not so sure. This mafia just lacks of so many opinions. Why the hell did everyone go inactive. There is 4 of us playing.

Because it was hosted later than it was planned for due to personal reasons ofc. They just got impatient and left (hazmah >.>), katana is busy with job applications and fark is having exams apparently

A new user who is quite active these days wanted to fill in as a sub, so maybe we replace him with hazmah?

"BEFORE SIGNING UP, PLEASE ASK YOURSELF "Do I have enough time to actively post during the day phase, at least three times a day, and submit my night action ever night?"

Duh. But moving on, Hazmah indeed for sure doesen't have a special role (Doctor, Sheriff,Wolf). That leave us that he is either a town folk or Mafioso. Odds are more on town, considering that there are 3 townfolks and 1 mafioso.

Yes i see people who sign up, which i know wont be active >.> lets just sub debi in

He gets a yes from me. He'll have to catch up though.

Well the thing is, you never know how long they will be afk really

And back to the game sorry Lux just wanted to be a lil' bit aggresive since not being so is not getting us anywhere....(all of these random pointings might actually get us to something though...)

All good buddy. It's all nature of the game.