DA Wolf Mafia #3 (Town Wins again!)

First topic message reminder :

























1. CrimsonOverlord
2. DanelerH
3. Lux
4. JC the shadow hunter
5. faervel
6. SilentKatana
7. hazmah
8. drunkion


To sign up, simply say "in".





Members of the winning faction will receive 1500 DP each. (You do not have to be alive at the end of the game to win unless you're the Wolf).

Last edited by Linda-Senpai on Wed Jun 15, 2016 11:28 pm; edited 12 times in total

/lynch lux 

I TOTALLY WON DIS GUIZ

LUX HAS BEEN LYNCHED! HE WAS THE WOLF! GAME HAS ENDED! TOWN WINS! DP IS BEING AWARDED

Full role list: 
Townsfolk - hazmah
Townsfolk - faervel
Townsfolk - DanelerH
Doctor - Drunkion
Sheriff - CrimsonOverlord

Godfather - SilentKatana
Mafioso - JC the Shadow Hunter 

Wolf - Lux

I've also wondered why the Wolf never attacks on Night 1.  I don't understand the point of that idea.  On the topic of the buff, the Mafia definitely need something to put the odds more in their favor.  I think that it's something that could at least be tried.  If nobody likes it, it can just be removed later.

Getting targeted by wolf at night as a godfather scared me, but if we have that buff then the wolf might miss a target? Idk

I didn't attack because it's what Wolf's been doing past rounds and because of probably my inexperience in the game. 

And I don't like that buff, unless you make it vice-versa, if wolf is targeted by the mafia he survives.

Why are you all considering buffing all these roles? Have you not looked at how broken this game is for the bad guys?
The ratio is 5-2-1.
There is a 57% chance for 2 towns to die N1 (Yes, my math was different before). That's already very detrimental for town. 

Imo Wolf should be taken out, but eh you might just keep it cos funz.

Edit: This also isn't the case of wolf rnging the scum and killing them all. I figured out everyone and that is how this came to be.

Linda, please start new one tonight. Besides mafia helps so much for forum activity.

Lux wrote:

Linda, please start new one tonight. Besides mafia helps so much for forum activity.

Need to figure out what type of game next one will be. Should it be another Wolf Mafia game? Or should this be the last Wolf Mafia game I host (since the intention of Wolf Mafia was to introduce everyone to the basics, and it's been 3 games already), and instead host a "Mini Mafia" game, which would have way more roles but still a small amount of players since we don't have the activity for a huge game (I've played games as big as 30 people). I'll put it to a poll and let you guys decide. 

Also @hazmah main reason I considered buffing Godfather is bc I was reading back on some of the games I played on Marriland and I realized that their Godfather was immune to being killed at Night except by a role called the Jailer, but that's Marriland Mafia and this is DA Mafia, so.

Last edited by Linda-Senpai on Thu Jun 16, 2016 3:31 am; edited 1 time in total

I  have voted for Mini mafia, if it does turn bad I guess we can switch back to Wolf Mafia.

I have been studying the game for a bit and I found out about some very interesting roles:

The traitor - A town player who works for mafia interests but appears as a town and can win only by a mafia win.

The Miller - innocent one but appears as mafia if investigated.

The Woodcutter - They can kill one person of their choice when they die.

Rabble Rouser - When alive, there are two lynchs every day.

Doublevoter - His vote counts twice 

Village drunk - additional role, must speak unclear and Gibberish.

The Dentist - during the night he picks a player and the player must remain silent during the next day. Other players would be notified that someone got shut down.

The Witch - She's shown during the night who will die and can choose to save them (can be used only once)

Village idiot - must convince town to kill them

There are more but I don't want to write them now.

Lux wrote:

I have been studying the game for a bit and I found out about some very interesting roles:

The traitor - A town player who works for mafia interests but appears as a town and can win only by a mafia win.

The Miller - innocent one but appears as mafia if investigated.

The Woodcutter - They can kill one person of their choice when they die.

Rabble Rouser - When alive, there are two lynchs every day.

Doublevoter - His vote counts twice 

Village drunk - additional role, must speak unclear and Gibberish.

The Dentist - during the night he picks a player and the player must remain silent during the next day. Other players would be notified that someone got shut down.

The Witch - She's shown during the night who will die and can choose to save them (can be used only once)

Village idiot - must convince town to kill them

There are more but I don't want to write them now.

The Traitor, Miller, and Woodcutter seem interesting, but I don't think our group could have all of them, even if we get a couple of extra people.

We definitely don't need the Rabble Rouser, since it's only a small group.

The Doublevoter could be good if we get an AFK player, but it would be even more interesting if it was a dual-option, so the Mafia could also have it.  The Dentist could be another interesting dual-option.

If we had the Witch, we would probably have to get rid of the Doctor, but I think the Witch should be able to save xemself since it's only once per game.

I would love to be either the Village Drunk or the Village Idiot.

Yes of course - we don't need all of them in one game lol. These were just examples, one or two more roles should do.

Something else that could be interesting is if we didn't know what roles were in the current game.  Instead, we just knew the potential ones.  For example, all of these roles would be listed in the opening post of game 4, but the only roles we use that game are Sheriff, Witch, Woodcutter, Idiot, Traitor, Godfather, and Mafioso Doublevoter.  The only roles we would know exist are our own and the Godfather could know that the Mafioso is a Doublevoter.

Hmm, interesting.

DanelerH wrote:

Something else that could be interesting is if we didn't know what roles were in the current game.  Instead, we just knew the potential ones.  For example, all of these roles would be listed in the opening post of game 4, but the only roles we use that game are Sheriff, Witch, Woodcutter, Idiot, Traitor, Godfather, and Mafioso Doublevoter.  The only roles we would know exist are our own and the Godfather could know that the Mafioso is a Doublevoter.

So basically a hidden role game?

hazmah wrote:

DanelerH wrote:

Something else that could be interesting is if we didn't know what roles were in the current game.  Instead, we just knew the potential ones.  For example, all of these roles would be listed in the opening post of game 4, but the only roles we use that game are Sheriff, Witch, Woodcutter, Idiot, Traitor, Godfather, and Mafioso Doublevoter.  The only roles we would know exist are our own and the Godfather could know that the Mafioso is a Doublevoter.

So basically a hidden role game?

Yeah, basically.  I think it would make things really interesting.

DanelerH wrote:

Something else that could be interesting is if we didn't know what roles were in the current game.  Instead, we just knew the potential ones.  For example, all of these roles would be listed in the opening post of game 4, but the only roles we use that game are Sheriff, Witch, Woodcutter, Idiot, Traitor, Godfather, and Mafioso Doublevoter.  The only roles we would know exist are our own and the Godfather could know that the Mafioso is a Doublevoter.

That's how Mafia is supposed to be tho. The only roles guaranteed to be in every game are Townsfolk, Sheriff, Doctor, and Godfather.

Linda-Senpai wrote:

DanelerH wrote:

Something else that could be interesting is if we didn't know what roles were in the current game.  Instead, we just knew the potential ones.  For example, all of these roles would be listed in the opening post of game 4, but the only roles we use that game are Sheriff, Witch, Woodcutter, Idiot, Traitor, Godfather, and Mafioso Doublevoter.  The only roles we would know exist are our own and the Godfather could know that the Mafioso is a Doublevoter.

That's how Mafia is supposed to be tho. The only roles guaranteed to be in every game are Townsfolk, Sheriff, Doctor, and Godfather.

Oh. Well, I guess that just shows how little I know about Mafia.  I still think we shouldn't have a Doctor if we have a Witch, though.

Why? Their roles are quite different.

Lux wrote:

I have been studying the game for a bit and I found out about some very interesting roles:

The traitor - A town player who works for mafia interests but appears as a town and can win only by a mafia win.

The Miller - innocent one but appears as mafia if investigated.

The Woodcutter - They can kill one person of their choice when they die.

Rabble Rouser - When alive, there are two lynchs every day.

Doublevoter - His vote counts twice 

Village drunk - additional role, must speak unclear and Gibberish.

The Dentist - during the night he picks a player and the player must remain silent during the next day. Other players would be notified that someone got shut down.

The Witch - She's shown during the night who will die and can choose to save them (can be used only once)

Village idiot - must convince town to kill them

There are more but I don't want to write them now.

The only one of those roles I like is The Traitor. And the Witch that I know is an Evil Neutral that fucks around with who people target at night.

I actually really hate the traitor. It's basically a mafia who shows up as town.

I will start Mini Mafia with the roles I used in the Mafia games I hosted here before. I just need to find them.

Well that was just example but I hope for more roles.