DA Wolf Mafia #3 (Town Wins again!)

First topic message reminder :

























1. CrimsonOverlord
2. DanelerH
3. Lux
4. JC the shadow hunter
5. faervel
6. SilentKatana
7. hazmah
8. drunkion


To sign up, simply say "in".





Members of the winning faction will receive 1500 DP each. (You do not have to be alive at the end of the game to win unless you're the Wolf).

Last edited by Linda-Senpai on Wed Jun 15, 2016 11:28 pm; edited 12 times in total

The doctor can confirm i was the one saved but that would put them at risk. Town will lose 1 is bad to town lol. Im merely looking for clues here. If someone died the next day why would you accuse someone else that currently isnt here? Im waiting to hear the defense for dan

I'm waiting for doctor to confirm that then, until then, I don't believe you and your alibi.

You are free to do so, but if the doctor self exposes at this stage town will lose someone incredibly valuable. Are you trying to lure in the doctor ?

Also i see no counter claim to my claim that i was shot, as in no other person claimed they were shot. I gave the alibi when no one was accusing me, so you cant say it was an attempt to save my skin at that moment

What do you mean by "[I keep] trying to skip the day"?  I made the suggestion once because we didn't have any information, then gave my reasoning for it.  Besides, if I were a Mafia, I would have tried giving slight nudges to lynch someone to make my work easier.

No that would make you too obvious. Also i dunno what evidence you want? Lets say a town dies or any other role dies the next day, what clue towards the culprit would that be? If anything another blind accusation will occur to get some info spilled, thats how the game works lol. If you are not mafia what do you claim to be ?

In order:
The main evidence I was hoping for was for the Sheriff to get more information, then xe is only able to check someone once a night.  We could also get potential information based on who died, as that may give us an idea on who decided to target xem.  This can also be done based on who was targeted, but was also healed, though I said this before you revealed you fit the bill for the latter.  If you want my input on this, you being the target doesn't help much in this case.  You're the best target since you played a major role in figuring out who the Mafia and the Wolf were during the last game.  Seeing as how we have only repeats and Hazmah, the latter of which said xe read over the last game, it could be any of us.

I claim to be a regular Town.  I am fully aware that only makes me sound more suspicious, as that's what a Mafia would say, but would you say differently?  This would be the claim from even the Doctor and the Sheriff, as claiming otherwise would put them at risk.

(On a side note, I have to go to work now, so I'll be gone for a few hours, but I'll try to check back while I'm eating lunch.)

Ive said this many times by now, if we skip the day and any of us dies its still the same track. For the sake of the argument lets say i die, so who are you gonna blame for it? Or just replace me with any other. See what im getting at? There are no clues in this until late to mid stage. I want to hear everybody's testimonies, as logically thats how you find holes.Trying to skip the day is highly disadvantageous for town, so that proposal puts you in my suspicion for now

I'm not calling out the doc, or I am, but I do not trust Crim's alibi at all,  at least not yet. There are too few opinions here until we can actually trust someone. Remember, JC did only one post, hazmah and fark none.

So who counter claims my testimony? My testimony is valid,because no one else said they were the ones getting shot.Also you made a mistake there, fark did indeed post and he encouraged the player who got shot to reveal himself, hence the arguments up to now. Calling out on the doc is a bad move to town, so either you slipped or you are the wolf/mafia trying to get rid of some power roles.

Crimson, I can't explain myself any better than I already have.  I realize that skipping the day might not be the best move, but we may end up having to do so.  If we're just going to point fingers to try to find out who the Mafia is, why didn't we do so during Day 1?

Because thats self explanatory, we didnt know this scenario would happen and you also already have a testimony. We can actually read people now, unlike day 1 when no one can argue about anything lol. We now have a 50-50 chance of hitting the mafia or wolf and you can only tell that by current behavior.Also last time i say this cuz it feels like im a broken record lol, let us say you skip day and i die or any other person dies. It will reveal who was town. Now then who will you blame for the kill? What would be the basis for the blame? Its just pressure to pinpoint some details. You can never tell who is who until very late game, so no what we are doing here isnt wrong, albeit its the only scenario we can take.

My mistake, I haven't read all of the previous replies..

At first, skipday option was pretty legit to me too tbh. But only now I realized what do you mean crims. Sorry, not sorry, I just do not trust anyone this early on the game. Still, if hazmah is one of the Mafia players, mafia loses for sure.

We can only get jc info late at night since that's when he signs in mostly. Don't think we gonna hear from hazmah at all this game,seeing as he kinda left (hope not,cuz an afk player kills the game badly)

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

We can only get jc info late at night since that's when he signs in mostly. Don't think we gonna hear from hazmah at all this game,seeing as he kinda left (hope not,cuz an afk player kills the game badly)

Yea but the thing is JC is on when I sleep. But I will stay little bit more tonight,considering that my school ends in two days anyways and I have nothing to study.

It is kinda frustrating that we dont have much input from the other players on this. Because of the same names always responding , the blame could be wrongly shifted

Weeeee, dont have school today

But from what Im hearing theres way too much anxiety, IN ALL HONESTY skipping the day would be too dangerous, not only does it give the mafia a chance to kill but also the wolf...... but also lynching would be just the same, since we can possibly kill one of our  own townsfolk or possibly even the doctor. I cant really raise my suspicion on anyone yet until I hear from (@SilentKatana , @Drunkion, @hazmah ) these are the players in which i barely have info on. but idk if we should either take the risk to lynch or not

If we dont lynch its a safe kill for the mafia. If we do lynch we have a 50-50 chance of hitting the evil roles. We should really analyze any slips during this whole ordeal

I think it's still to early to lynch anyone. When does Day 2 end?

Tomorrow at midnight. I presented the alternatives that lead due to lynching or not lynching. I still strongly suggest we lynch. I already have gotten some clues due to this debate

Hm, that's good. We still have some time to do the right lynch.

Yeah absolutely. I don't advise we lynch AT THIS MOMENT, rather wait a bit for the other testimonies

I wanted to say the same thing.

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

Yeah absolutely. I don't advise we lynch AT THIS MOMENT, rather wait a bit for the other testimonies

Isnt this what we've been saying like the entire time? (  )

No the others said to skip day and lynch the next day

While I have no leads on who the Mafia is, I do have a small idea of who the Wolf might be.  I'll give my opinion if you guys want it, but I don't think it would be beneficial.  If I'm wrong, it's just mindless finger-pointing.  If I'm right, it still does us no good.  It's not good for the Wolf to die yet, as that puts the Town at a disadvantage to the Mafia.

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

No the others said to skip day and lynch the next day

I thought me,you,and lux decided that lynching tiday would be beneficial if we can get more input

Last edited by JC the shadow hunter on Thu Jun 09, 2016 2:20 am; edited 1 time in total

SilentKatana wrote:

Again, apologies for not being so active atm, been a bit hectic on my end. I personally have no real clue as to whom to hit so far, as again, we do have no real evidence at this point. I could go out on an incredibly tenuous limb and say Crimson's constant asking for people to deny the validity of his claim is suspicious, but that is by far the most twisted logic I could come up with. It is most definitely not good logic, which is my point.

As such, I really would need to actually hear any evidence people would have on suspecting people, as I am totally in the dark as of right now, and do not want to make twisted logic branches...

And yea, at this point we lack not only the evidence but the people who are playing lol, this is like the only thing thats makes this game not as fun as it should be