DA Wolf Mafia #2 (Town wins!)

First topic message reminder :



























To sign up, simply say "in".




Members of the winning faction will receive 1500 DP each. (You do not have to be alive at the end of the game to win unless you're the Wolf).

Last edited by Linda-Senpai on Mon May 30, 2016 12:12 am; edited 15 times in total

This is getting really interesting. Lux gave quite the defense argument however dont we risk the same blindly judging jc? We were trying to lynch lux based on evidence,but still felt halfhearted about it. We can randomly lynch jc sure,but its the same reason katana isnt getting lynched. No actual argument vs him.

Well JC said it would be the best to eliminate me. Seems like he's trying to clear his path, something a mafia player would do.

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

This is getting really interesting. Lux gave quite the defense argument however dont we risk the same blindly judging jc? We were trying to lynch lux based on evidence,but still felt halfhearted about it. We can randomly lynch jc sure,but its the same reason katana isnt getting lynched. No actual argument vs him.

The thing is, I'm saying we shouldn't lynch lux because of the evidence. At this point, we need to look at the little hints that might hint people as mafia, etc... JC has been going along very passively with the events that have been transpiring, and he did have that one oddity when he started posting... Like, it is in character for him not to notice Drunk was dead, but then, it's almost too much of a typical JC move, as if it was made for us to dismiss. At any rate, I think that warrants some form of suspicion...

For what it's worth i dont think jc is mafia. He asked for drunk's opinion lol. Surely a mafia player would know who died at least. U dont start your questions like that as mafia. The sudden shift on jc from both you and lux really does raise my suspicions even more. Luc directly agreed to jv being mafia and he also used the pressure bluff, which might lead to him even being godfather

Jc* le typos 2op

Well you have to indeed consider that JC is a new player and that he's JC (so I'm not surprised he didn't know about Mark's death)

From all of the talk here ive come to some little assumptions. Now lux pressures us to think that he is sheriff,because he says if we kill him now we hurt the town late game. We do know the sheriff is the most worthy role late game for the town, however hear me out on this one. Why would a sheriff, who supposedly has knowledge of at least 1 person per night, accuse 2 people blindly? Yeah he wouldnt do that, neither would he take the risk of him coming out so early due to pressure and what not. From this deduction lux is mafia. 

Moving on to katana. His constant protection of lux and his confidence in being town makes me to believe he is the godfather. Think about it, its a solid alibi. If he were to live today and still get investigated by the sheriff hed appear as town. The godfather doesnt want his henchmen to die, thus he keeps protecting lux while also shifting the blame to jc.

We also pinpointed that username is indeed townsfolk (he uh got a bit nervous but its ok it helped us in the end). This concludes my deduction for now. Feel free to notice me of any flaws in my logic.

ill also /unlynch lux ; /lynch katana 


i gave my reasoning behind this and itd be nice if all the others took the time to read it carefully

CrimsonOverlord wrote:

From all of the talk here ive come to some little assumptions. Now lux pressures us to think that he is sheriff,because he says if we kill him now we hurt the town late game. We do know the sheriff is the most worthy role late game for the town, however hear me out on this one. Why would a sheriff, who supposedly has knowledge of at least 1 person per night, accuse 2 people blindly? Yeah he wouldnt do that, neither would he take the risk of him coming out so early due to pressure and what not. From this deduction lux is mafia. 

Moving on to katana. His constant protection of lux and his confidence in being town makes me to believe he is the godfather. Think about it, its a solid alibi. If he were to live today and still get investigated by the sheriff hed appear as town. The godfather doesnt want his henchmen to die, thus he keeps protecting lux while also shifting the blame to jc.

We also pinpointed that username is indeed townsfolk (he uh got a bit nervous but its ok it helped us in the end). This concludes my deduction for now. Feel free to notice me of any flaws in my logic.

Those are some very good points you've made.  I'm still not entirely convinced we have enough evidence to lynch Katana, but what you're saying makes sense.  If Katana really is the Godfather, lynching xem would be great because the sheriff wouldn't have to worry about that anymore.  Alright, I'll lynch Katana, too.

/unlynch Lux
/lynch Katana

I still reserve my douts, lux still eshows wolf signs to me but i can see the arguement for him being a sheriff aswell, does seem kat is rather defending him i guess, but this is leading to his own suspicion, to which he's not really defending himself well on that basis to much of a worry towards lux, possibly lux is the farther and kats the lacky protecting not certain but a good hunch.

/lynch Katana

sorry pissed up the vote thing

Thats 4 votes so we need one more. Depending on the person giving the last vote this could reveal many things. If lux wants to get our trust imo he should vote for katana, to really prove that he is on the justice side

You keep saying you are town and in the case the sheriff investigates a godfather and he appears as town your testimony checks in. This is the main reason i doubt you and wanna prove it. I wont go back on my word sorry. Its either you or lux that have had holes this entire case

Check-in before I go. This turned out interesting...I will see how the situation will turn in next coming hours, my brother has a promotion night.

Graduation night in fact lol he finished high school.

nice, oh just dropping in to see how is this going

This seems interesting...I'm suspicious about both @DanelerH and @SilentKatana...I wonder why you didn't Katana Lynch Dan fee posts earlier?? You did it after there was 2-3 Lynchs on you...and you also tried to shift blame to JC. You are kinda panicking...however, I was the first one to be suspicious about Daneler, maybe Katana shifted to him to gain my trust. But he really made me think. If I lock the Lynch now on Katana, this could be over as mafia player will slip away...I will see how the situation will turn in next 3 hours when I will be back. If nothing changes drastically, I am going to lock the Lynch on Katana.

Actually even if we miss with kats town wont lose now that i think about it. Why? Because yes town will lose one member but the wolf has to kill the mafia next night to ensure he doesnt lose. If mafia and town are the same number mafia wins, if mafia overpowers town mafia also wins. I guess its safe to say that the wolf will most likely kill a mafia player next night if things indeed go bad for us.

Sorry, Kat.

/Lynch Katana

actually i /unlynch katana 

Interesting Crims, what made you unlynch?

Let me reason behind this. Isnt it strange that 2 are left unvoted? Username and jc. There are 3 mafias in the game.Majority agreed on killing katana which reveals the major flaw here. If katana is godfather as i deduced it wouldnt make sense for his henchmen to kill him off now would it? So guys unlynch now and go lynch for lux. The trap was set albeit a risky one.

lux or dan are my main priorities now tbh but read my theory first

It was crucial to lure in some info im afraid >.< but lets critically think now

ok i'm back and HOLY FRIG ok..um .. i just have to catch up to the last (1,2,3) 30 posts(oh goodness) and then... i don't know.. think of something