Our Lost Pieces [Part II: Game Over]

Olethros wrote:

UNVOTE: The Brodie
VOTE: Tricmagic


I'd like to see what comes from this exchange. At the moment, whilst I don't necessarily doubt that Tric has the role they claimed, I don't necessarily believe them either. Maf could easily claim a weaker town role to maybe slip under the radar in terms of voting. Going by the fact that Tric has been using this "Honest" line for the whole game, it kinda suggests to me that this could be pre-planned

jjh927 wrote:

Now, does anyone have even the slightest remaining concern or can I continue to act as town leader?

kyosuke kiryu wrote:

Wait for alisae VC but I'm not lynching debi at least not for this day. I already stated my reasons before Faer.

faervel wrote:

kyosuke kiryu wrote:

Wait for alisae VC but I'm not lynching debi at least not for this day. I already stated my reasons before Faer.

Yeah I understand. Who's your to lynch atm?(Besides jj)

Debi wrote:

If you don't think your going to survive the night JJ why not just tell us your role? It makes little sense to me. You are dropping tons of 'hints' as to what your role is. So why not just tell us? All of this hesitation such as, wanting to wait for others opinions, or, wanting to wait until the end of the day kind of makes me suspicious.
If we consider when I came back after 'lurking' for the first time. You asked me something, and I asked for your opinion in return. You decided you would wait, until somebody had an opinion that wasn't based off of your own. It was posted kind of soon. As an example, lets say you were Scum, could this be asking for help as to what to do? Maybe, who knows? Lets consider this situation. Somebody has a role, and they are dropping tons of hints, they are ignoring all role reveal claims, yet somehow somebody else knows what the other person's role is, (despite the fact they could be lying). Both Scum maybe?
Anyways back to the main point at hand, people want you to reveal, reveal, else we will start thinking your lying
@jjh927

jjh927 wrote:

No.

It is against the interests of the town for me to reveal my role right now. You have no reason to believe I am lying, because if I am lying I am getting lynched D2. Therefore I am telling the truth.

Debi wrote:

jjh927 wrote:

No.

It is against the interests of the town for me to reveal my role right now. You have no reason to believe I am lying, because if I am lying I am getting lynched D2. Therefore I am telling the truth.

That isn't how it works at all, if it is against the interests of town for you to reveal now, its the same for day 2. I do have reason to believe you are lying, as you are talking nonstop as to how important your role is, but you aren't telling us, therefore you are probably lying as to how important it is. You aren't doctor else, you wouldn't be rattling on so much as to how important your role is. So reveal, as you legit are coming across as somebody who is lying about their role importance. If you don't want us to think that, tell us your role. Also you can't expect us to believe you without reasoning or evidence, that goes against the entire foundation of mafia.

faervel wrote:

Debi wrote:

If you don't think your going to survive the night JJ why not just tell us your role? It makes little sense to me. You are dropping tons of 'hints' as to what your role is. So why not just tell us? All of this hesitation such as, wanting to wait for others opinions, or, wanting to wait until the end of the day kind of makes me suspicious.
If we consider when I came back after 'lurking' for the first time. You asked me something, and I asked for your opinion in return. You decided you would wait, until somebody had an opinion that wasn't based off of your own. It was posted kind of soon. As an example, lets say you were Scum, could this be asking for help as to what to do? Maybe, who knows? Lets consider this situation. Somebody has a role, and they are dropping tons of hints, they are ignoring all role reveal claims, yet somehow somebody else knows what the other person's role is, (despite the fact they could be lying). Both Scum maybe?
Anyways back to the main point at hand, people want you to reveal, reveal, else we will start thinking your lying
@jjh927

Actually I wanna see you role-reveal more atm...But for now:

Let's pause till Alisae comes? That way we'll have a proper VC, replacement will get their vote and the people currently not fully caught on(including the new Lux) will have an easier time catching-on.

PEdit:The only way I see Bladecharge being scum is being partners with jj and if jj manages to convince us of not being scum I think he's safe. I am with you on the other 2 though.

DanelerH wrote:

Debi wrote:

jjh927 wrote:

No.

It is against the interests of the town for me to reveal my role right now. You have no reason to believe I am lying, because if I am lying I am getting lynched D2. Therefore I am telling the truth.

That isn't how it works at all, if it is against the interests of town for you to reveal now, its the same for day 2. I do have reason to believe you are lying, as you are talking nonstop as to how important your role is, but you aren't telling us, therefore you are probably lying as to how important it is. You aren't doctor else, you wouldn't be rattling on so much as to how important your role is. So reveal, as you legit are coming across as somebody who is lying about their role importance. If you don't want us to think that, tell us your role. Also you can't expect us to believe you without reasoning or evidence, that goes against the entire foundation of mafia.

Except there is a reason to believe him.  He claims that his role is one that is used during the Day and that it will apparently be proven by the end of Day 1.  If he is lying, he will be the Day 2 lynch.