Our Lost Pieces [Part I: Game Over]

First topic message reminder :

Player list:
1. kyosuke kiryu
2. faervel
3. vequest The Brodie (Lux's Alt)
4. DanelerH
5. CrimsonOverlord skeletronlord
6. jjh927
7. Debi
8. Wingshine
9. Linda-Senpai
10. TricMagic
11. Olethros
12. Bladecharge
13. EchoVision

Game rules:
1) All decisions come down to a democracy. The moderator gets 14 votes.
2) Please place your votes using the following code. While using bold tags to place your vote is okay, using the following would be prefered. Your vote will not get counted if it's not bolded.:

3) Lynches will occur when one player has received the majority of votes. You may post during the twilight period between the hammer and the closing of the thread.
4) If unsufficient votes are made on any player, or a majority of votes have been made to no lynch, no lynch will be made.
5) Nights will last 48 hours.
6) Do NOT quote any private communication from me, nor any mason, scum, neighbour, or anything topics that may or may not exist. You may paraphrase, just don't copy it wholesale.
7) You MAY NOT discuss the game outside of the thread unless your role specifically gives you the ability to do so. The acception to this is any neighboorhoods, Scum PT, or masonry PTs you are involved in. I really feel like I should not be bolding this acception but whatever
Days will last 7 irl days, or until a lynch (or no lynch) has been decided on.
9) Blue (#0099ff) is my color. Refrain from using it.
10) In the tragic event I drop off the face of the earth, @Nightbot will take my place and he has no say in this .
11) Death is final, but a single contentless "bah!" post will be permitted, just make sure it has no content in said post.
12) The rules can be arbitrarily changed/added to by one party (me) anytime I am feeling greedy and/or evil.
13) Players not use factional and individual actions simultaneously unless their role PM explicitly says otherwise.
14) This setup is non-bastard.
15) Be nice, and try to enjoy yourself. BTW I'll send prods every 48 hours. Something like that.
16) Prod rules will be extremely strict. If you are going V/LA either inform me or put up V/LA flags. I will be very quick to replace for inactivity.
17) This setup will be reviewed.
18) hahaha I totally stole this rules thingy from a friend.

Setup Information:
1) The setup is confirmed as having 10 Town-Aligned players and 2 Scum-Aligned players. The 13th player's alignment may be {Town, Scum, Serial Killer}. Traitors and similar count as scum.
2) Alignments were randomized independent on picks. Flavour is not alignment indicative.
3) Only one pick is required but you can send three to make my life easier if you want.
4) From the day the game fills you have 2 days to send in a pick. Failure to do so and I will pick for you.
5) The game will be non-bastard and role madness.

Dead (6/13) :

Part 1: http://www.duelacademy.net/t49851-our-lost-pieces-part-i-d1
Part 2: http://www.duelacademy.net/t49938-our-lost-pieces-part-ii-d1

Last edited by Alisae on Wed May 10, 2017 2:18 am; edited 18 times in total

Offical Votecount 1.3! Debi (2) - Wingshine, TricMagic [L-5] (Leading Wagon) TricMagic (2) - EchoVision, Debi [L-5] (Counterwagon) DanelerH (2) - Linda-Senpai, Olethros [L-5] fearvel (1) - DanelerH [L-6] Wingshine (1) - skeletonlord [L-6] Not Voting (5) - The Brodie, kyosuke kiryu, jjh927, bladecharge, faervel With 13 alive, it is 7 to lynch. The day will end at 4/30/17 at 12am or if majority has been reached. Extras Changes From the Last Votecount : Player Vote History Day 1 : Players Who Have BEEN Voted Day 1 : Voting Chronology Day 1 :

Last edited by Alisae on Sun Apr 23, 2017 4:36 pm; edited 2 times in total

Fuck the coding stuff on my phone 

Vote: Dan

Okay Alisae

VOTE: Dan

happy?

Hi

The Brodie wrote:

Hi

Hi


/unvote DanelerH


/vote The Brodie

DanelerH wrote:

Actually, I suppose it was a bit of a poor wording on my part.  Regardless, some good still came out of it. I have a Town-lean on Linda now.  I don't think scum would find that worth pushing, bit Town would. 

So she's a Town-lean already? Why? For what? Just a reminder, game was in a Pre-Game mode and only 46% of players have actually joined the discussion at that moment. So I'm asking you again, what does make her Town-lean then SO EARLY in the game?

The Brodie wrote:

DanelerH wrote:

Actually, I suppose it was a bit of a poor wording on my part.  Regardless, some good still came out of it. I have a Town-lean on Linda now.  I don't think scum would find that worth pushing, bit Town would. 

So she's a Town-lean already? Why? For what? Just a reminder, game was in a Pre-Game mode and only 46% of players have actually joined the discussion at that moment. So I'm asking you again, what does make her Town-lean then SO EARLY in the game?

I already explained this, but maybe you haven't read that far yet.  I'll go ahead an quote it.

DanelerH wrote:

faervel wrote:

I find your town-lean on Linda this early untrustable and a tad bit scummy.

Reasoning:There aren't many benefits of announcing a town-lean this early into the game. I see it as an attempt to gain Linda's trust...

Then I shall explain my read a bit more.  Scum are overly concerned with keeping up a Town appearance.  Let's say Linda had started a wagon and I was lynched by the end of Day 1.  Scum don't want a mislynch traced back to them.  It's much better for Town to begin the mislynch, then support it if they find it worth it.  As such, I find Linda more likely to be Town.  Granted, it isn't too strong of a reason (hence "lean"), but reads are always subject to change.

DanelerH wrote:

The Brodie wrote:

DanelerH wrote:

Actually, I suppose it was a bit of a poor wording on my part.  Regardless, some good still came out of it. I have a Town-lean on Linda now.  I don't think scum would find that worth pushing, bit Town would. 

So she's a Town-lean already? Why? For what? Just a reminder, game was in a Pre-Game mode and only 46% of players have actually joined the discussion at that moment. So I'm asking you again, what does make her Town-lean then SO EARLY in the game?

I already explained this, but maybe you haven't read that far yet.  I'll go ahead an quote it.

DanelerH wrote:

faervel wrote:

I find your town-lean on Linda this early untrustable and a tad bit scummy.

Reasoning:There aren't many benefits of announcing a town-lean this early into the game. I see it as an attempt to gain Linda's trust...

Then I shall explain my read a bit more.  Scum are overly concerned with keeping up a Town appearance.  Let's say Linda had started a wagon and I was lynched by the end of Day 1.  Scum don't want a mislynch traced back to them.  It's much better for Town to begin the mislynch, then support it if they find it worth it.  As such, I find Linda more likely to be Town.  Granted, it isn't too strong of a reason (hence "lean"), but reads are always subject to change.

Yeah, sorry. I was catching up and the moment I saw your post I decided to react. It's probably a bad habit I need to change. I do understand your reasonings, but I still don't understand why did you give your 'reads' on Linda that early. I mean, it was pre-game, it's not really serious, but it's still catching my attention. Tbh, I don't possess town-read abilities, but I can't tell who's town-lean or scum-lean this early haha.

@The Brodie, what do you think of Debi an xyr thoughts of being targeted?

Well, I can understand Debi's frustration because of the previous games we've played together. But it all looks like a random lynching (I think that it is??) for me, so I don't really get why Debi reacted to those lynches. I agree it's a paranoid move.

three pages already wow that a lot for a couple of hours

The Brodie wrote:

Well, I can understand Debi's frustration because of the previous games we've played together. But it all looks like a random lynching (I think that it is??) for me, so I don't really get why Debi reacted to those lynches. I agree it's a paranoid move.

You're supposed to react to a vote, that's the point of a vote being on you in the first place. You're not, however, supposed to overreact.

Linda-Senpai wrote:

The Brodie wrote:

Well, I can understand Debi's frustration because of the previous games we've played together. But it all looks like a random lynching (I think that it is??) for me, so I don't really get why Debi reacted to those lynches. I agree it's a paranoid move.

You're supposed to react to a vote, that's the point of a vote being on you in the first place. You're not, however, supposed to overreact.

Not reacting is also a reaction.

my leg be killing me right now

@Linda-Senpai, what do you think about Debi's reaction? Do you think the self-consciousness of being "targeted" in RVS is alignment indicative and, if so, does it come from Town or scum?

Bladecharge wrote:

my leg be killing me right now

We don't care. That doesn't pertain to the game. What do you think of things that have been going on so far?

Offical Votecount 1.4! DanelerH (2) - Olethros, kyosuke kiryu [L-5] (Leading Wagon) TricMagic (2) - EchoVision, Debi [L-5] (Counterwagon) Debi (2) - Wingshine, TricMagic [L-5] fearvel (1) - DanelerH [L-6] Wingshine (1) - skeletonlord [L-6] The Brodie (1) - Linda-Senpai [L-6] Not Voting (4) - The Brodie, jjh927, bladecharge, faervel The day will end at 4/30/17 at 12am or if majority has been reached. Extras Changes From the Last Votecount : Player Vote History Day 1 : Players Who Have BEEN Voted Day 1 : Voting Chronology Day 1 :

Last edited by Alisae on Sun Apr 23, 2017 4:35 pm; edited 4 times in total

DanelerH wrote:

@Linda-Senpai, what do you think about Debi's reaction?  Do you think the self-consciousness of being "targeted" in RVS is alignment indicative and, if so, does it come from Town or scum?

I'm going to need to see more out of him before I can say on this. It leaves a real sour taste in my mouth, but then we have to remember that last game he self-lynched himself as town, so this is hardly a surprise.

What do i think?well just random voting it seems. So I have no real vote yet.

Bladecharge wrote:

What do i think?well just random voting it seems. So I have no real vote yet.

I'll ask you the same question I asked Lux, then. What do you think of Debi and xyr thoughts of being targeted.

@Debi, why do you feel targeted? It's only two RVS votes on you, then you went and did the same to Tric (two votes).

That does seem kind fo suspicious when I did my first vote it was at random if any of them are new that might be the case. just toughing it out their.

I will tell you what I think about the vote on Debi...you guys are going based on what happened on previous game, when in reality we were all wrong last game. I mean not trying to defend Debi, but I would definitely wait until Debi posts more, so we should be waiting for Debi's reaction...

Then again I want to know what @tricmagic has to say about being also targeted by 2 people and being counter wagon

Ya i say wait

kyosuke kiryu wrote:

I will tell you what I think about the vote on Debi...you guys are going based on what happened on previous game, when in reality we were all wrong last game. I mean not trying to defend Debi, but I would definitely wait until Debi posts more, so we should be waiting for Debi's reaction...

The pressure on Debi is from his (over)reaction to the RVS, specially the bit "already" is as if Debi was EXPECTING to be targeted.
But agreed I should wait as well on the reaction...
So for now...(going on in next post cause my multi-quote skills are a failure)

The Brodie wrote:

Linda-Senpai wrote:

The Brodie wrote:

Well, I can understand Debi's frustration because of the previous games we've played together. But it all looks like a random lynching (I think that it is??) for me, so I don't really get why Debi reacted to those lynches. I agree it's a paranoid move.

You're supposed to react to a vote, that's the point of a vote being on you in the first place. You're not, however, supposed to overreact.

Not reacting is also a reaction.

Bladecharge wrote:

my leg be killing me right now

Bladecharge wrote:

Ya i say wait

The posts above are written just for the sake of being written. They provide nothing to the game but I'm getting the feeling that they are there so that they are not considered to be "lurking" but they don't want to push it too far. #ScumVibe

Also Lux: "Tbh, I don't possess town-read abilities, but I can't tell who's town-lean or scum-lean this early haha.
"(#QuoteSkills)
Scumvibe but this one I can't explain much...more of a meta read...

Last edited by Alisae on Sun Apr 23, 2017 5:15 am; edited 1 time in total