Duel Academy
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Duel Academy Log in

Get your game on!


Duel academy RPG!

power_settings_newLogin to reply
+12
YgoBeast247
Necruta
YAMI MOTO#1
DanelerH
Booked
niney16
Alisae
Kangaroo-Jolty
username290
Pepchoninga
PowerNova
CrimsonOverlord
16 posters

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyDuel academy RPG!

more_horiz
First topic message reminder :

So some of you remember the idea we once came up with. Our very own roleplay rpg consisting of dueling through various seasons of the ygo anime and such. Now i see people are still hype for this so i want to discuss what you guys would like to have and not have, so that i can work on this to give all a good experience. Discuss below!

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Is the lack of Divine Winds of the Mist Valley intended or just forgotten?

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
I forgot that was a card lmao

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Pepchoninga wrote:
I belive cards like Cyber-Stein, Yata, Disk-Commander, Witch of the black forest, Sangan, Mind Master and even Change of hearts, should be given a chance. They are either too risky in a format like that (Cyber-Stein), or there are much more broken cards in today's game imo. The other cards in that section should be banned imo, if that is what you meant (Didn't really get what you meant in your first sentence tbh.) 


I'm assuming you're referring to this section:
Newly Semi-Limited :


In your banlist, I don't know if these were oversights, but you never listed them, which made them Semi-Limited.  I felt like they should be moved to Limited, instead.


Faervel wrote:
Is the lack of Divine Winds of the Mist Valley intended or just forgotten?

I don't know about Pep, but it was intentional for me.  The same is true with Genex Ally Birdman.  However, since we are also unbanning Elemenal HERO Stratos, Divine Wind FTK is playable again.  I had forgotten about this, so measures should probably be taken to prevent it.  The simplest solution would be to ban Blaze Fenix, the Burning Bombardment Bird.  This will also prevent several other FTKs.

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
If faervel gets Divine Winds of Mist Valley can I get my emergency teleport

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Hell no. Anyway @danelerh you seem to be good with lists, mind posting a finalized one that you think we should use?

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
wait wtf, y is this starting lol, you found all the villains yet? ._.

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Yeah kinda. Me, fark, powernova, you? Well 3 villains aint bad for now. I can still recruit more

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
But I refuse. One of my favorite things is to say "NO" right in the face of someone who thinks they are strong.

I mean, lol since when u started that assumption that I duel ._.

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
DA RP Banlist Proposition

Notes :

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Bookingly wrote:
But I refuse. One of my favorite things is to say "NO" right in the face of someone who thinks they are strong.

I mean, lol since when u started that assumption that I duel ._.

You dueled the most. Just get ygopro now that you even have a guide and help out.

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Now keep in mind, we cannot prevent every OTK. Even if they are posible with the cards that are unbanned, the highlander rule canceles most of the OTKs around, as they are based on fast play and consistency in making them. 


My opinion still stands about the frog situation. Swap Frog is there real bread and butter, there biggest combo starter and without it, nobody will use frogs. I will also say I haven't been playing when those cards were at there best (at least not truly playing) so I cannot tell how powerful they will truly are. I'll have to go neutral on this, and trust Dan with the decision. 


Again, Magical Scientist and Makyura the Destructor are cards that people probably won't use even if unbanned. We can put them at limited and will probably never ever hear from them, unless some crazy ass person decides to experiment.


Same here. Devine Wind FTK, will almost be impossible with the highlander rule imo. I didn't think of the card (I guess Dan got though every single fucking card lol), but if you want to prevent it, sure go ahead, it wouldn't change anything. 


In the end we are talking about little things that won't make a true impact on the experience. If there are any cards that will do and I or Dan have missed, that is where we should focus. All those FTKs and OTKs will have a 30% success rate AT BEST. The chances of it getting out of hand is even lower, as there are ways to prevent some of those things. Another thing is people will probably want decks that will consistently work for them. People won't really think of playing this old ass shit FTK/OTK deck. ALSO 3rd point, let's not forget there will be a deck judge. If a deck seems to be abusing any specific OTK/FTK that the deck judge thing might hurt the game it will not be allowed. 


@DanelerH @CrimsonOverlord @faervel

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Anyway sadly only 3 up for villains up to now. Any suggestions? Also when would you like this launched?

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Well i would say launch it on the 1st of October, but put the sign-ups like 2 weeks before or something.

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Bump* dis shet cannot go unnoticed

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
CrimsonOverlord wrote:
Anyway sadly only 3 up for villains up to now. Any suggestions? Also when would you like this launched?

I'd be up but don't you think 3is enough for a small group like ours...?If we got more people joining(which I hope we do) then I'd gladly join the dark side.

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Welp 4 is a good number imo. 4th one should be a final boss so yeah. Welp anyway expect an announcement of this soon enough, then we can arrange things.

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Lol, depending on the amount of people joining, you should increase the number villains. Tho as I said, You could play multiple villains. Or have a staff member play/post in the RP/RPG, but one of you 4 play the games. 

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Nah i wanna be the villain by myself as in , the words i speak and the actions i take. Well what if we make it that the duelists who lose the duels become possessed or something like that. These are shadow games, so penalties must exist

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
You will be one. 


What I mean is for it to be able to have more villains. (And not have 2 completly played by the same person.) you can have another staff say the words and you play the duels on his behalf.) 

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Yeah thats what i said. I wanna be able to say the words, not have someone else do it for me lol. Anyway read the punishment idea

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Welp tbh, you will have to make some exceptions for the thing to be made. 


I've read everything...what is this punishment idea? 

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Updated Banlist

New Additions :


Level Eater is currently up for debate.  It has been banned in the OCG.  Does anyone think it should be banned here?

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Tbh one *person(Next lvl grammars) talking and the other one playing just...sucks.
But if it's REALLY needed learn a thing or 2 from @Yarn Tethers...Playing on more than 1 character shouldn't be hard if it's needed(Says the guy who's simply awful at RPs :3 )

Last edited by faervel on Fri Sep 16, 2016 7:04 pm; edited 1 time in total

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
@Pepchoninga ( @CrimsonOverlord )
Pretty sure what Crims means is liek....after losing a duel(s) to a shadow duelist one should become one too.

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Unban Barkion. There is no need to ban a card that doesn't really do THAT much. 

Keep in mind that highlander rules, makes synchro decks much slower, since they sometimes can't get to there resources that quicky. I personally think that level eater wont hurt as much. Or just ban Librarian lol. 

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
I'm suggesting that mostly because it would look kinda weird  having the same guy play 2 villains tbh. 


Also I'm not really liking the idea of that tbh. While it could make for some good twists, it's not how shadow duels work. This should be left for a Society of Light type of storyline. 

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Then what risk would a shadow game posses? Just lose and shake hands? lol ,there has to be something sinister, like turning your allies against you, or getting rid of them for good

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Well, I don't know tbh. One thing to note tho. The villains decks should not be too good. They should be decks, that everybody could defeat. Maybe have the final baddy have a better deck to make things more interesting. That's why I think there should be around 6-7 shadow duelists. So many of the members will be able to have a shot at one of them. 

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
Pepchoninga wrote:
Well, I don't know tbh. One thing to note tho. The villains decks should not be too good. They should be decks, that everybody could defeat. Maybe have the final baddy have a better deck to make things more interesting. That's why I think there should be around 6-7 shadow duelists. So many of the members will be able to have a shot at one of them. 

I disagree. their decks shouldn't be bad if you also disagree with the idea of no penalty to losing to shadow duelists(well..not sure if you do...) cause it'd be like...too easy that way;Getting multiple tries vs a deck that's not so hard to beat...?
Also the number of shadows can be discussed after the sign-ups are over..but still I think 6is too much(Imagine having 6mafias...)

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
We are making the game very luck based in many ways. But we are also getting back the old days. Then, certain decks were better then others. And the idea of the RP is not like who will win. Bad guys or good guys. So your reference to mafia, doesn't really make sence. Villains are ultimately there, to be defeated. And if it is TOO hard from them to be defeated, people will get tired or bored. I'm saying there should be a well thought system. Some are easier, some are harder. And you will know if you are gonna challenge the big bad, you are gonna have to prepare for the duel of your life. 

descriptionDuel academy RPG!  - Page 4 EmptyRe: Duel academy RPG!

more_horiz
privacy_tip Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
power_settings_newLogin to reply