Saber Hole ruling

hi guys,

was playing YGOPRO and have that happened,

i was have XX-Saber Faultroll and XX-Saber Ragigura face-up in atk possion and Saber Hole as a set trap .

my opponent activate Monster Reborn to summon monster from my grave, but the game didn't ask me to chain my Saber Hole.

Saber Hole activate when i have face-up X-Saber monster , then
XX-Saber monster considerd X-Saber monsters too, aren't it ?

i start to doubt myself for that, I'm right or there r a bug in the game ?

its not an inhernet summon or its summoned via/by a card effect
/end

Last edited by Placido on Fri Jan 25, 2013 2:47 pm; edited 1 time in total

Saber Hole can only negate a summon by the following means: Inherit Special Summon, Normal Summon, Flip Summon. It cannot negate a summon via card effect such as Monster Reborn.

Last edited by Train Hardnett on Fri Jan 25, 2013 2:54 pm; edited 1 time in total

Train Hardnett wrote:

Saber Whole can only negate a summon by the following means: Inherit Special Summon, Normal Summon, Flip Summon. It cannot negate a summon via card effect such as Monster Reborn.

Means, it can negate all summons BUT those by card effects, like most Fusion Summons ("Contact Fusions" like Chimeratech Fortress Dragon, Gladiator Beast Gyzarus, etc. CAN be negated by Saber Hole, but no other Fusion Summon), Ritual Summons or summons by effects like Monster Reborn, Abyss-Sphere etc.

Last edited by Behemoth on Fri Jan 25, 2013 2:52 pm; edited 1 time in total

What Train and Irate says is true.

However for future, yes XX-Sabers are also X-Sabers because they both have X-Saber in their name and thus are consider part of the same archetype.

Train Hardnett wrote:

Saber Whole can only negate a summon by the following means: Inherit Special Summon, Normal Summon, Flip Summon. It cannot negate a summon via card effect such as Monster Reborn.

thanks but more explanation of meaning of Inherit Special Summon ?

RAI wrote:

Train Hardnett wrote:

Saber Whole can only negate a summon by the following means: Inherit Special Summon, Normal Summon, Flip Summon. It cannot negate a summon via card effect such as Monster Reborn.

thanks but more explanation of meaning of Inherit Special Summon ?

A Summon that does not start a Chain, like Cyber Dragon.

thanks

Anymore questions?

no thanks that all ^ ^

Answered~

So locked~