Umm let's see...
Fate/Stay Night - An amazing anime. The story line is incredible and the plot is as well. Lots of emotions thrown around, lol.
Witchblade - Currently my #1 on my top 5. Besides the fact that the main character becoming half naked when she transforms, the plot is deep. Mainly a mother/daughter relationship that appeals to your emotions. And it's very funny. ^^
School Rumble - Hilariously cute anime. The third season was never made though. -_- I could read the manga to see what I missed but I don't read mangas.
Maburaho - Lol, this was a wierd one. xD In the world of magic, you are only allowed to use spells a certain number of times, depending on your ability. Some can use their magic many times, thousands or more, and some can use it fewer times. Once your magic count hits 0, you turn to ash. The main character can only use it 8 times. However, three important families discover that he is the descendant from a line of amazing magicians. So each sends a girl to marry and/or "take his genes". It's basically a lust to love anime. The ending was lame but I ignored it. :D
Burst Angel: This would probably be the girl version of Black Cat... sort of. xD Except they fight with machines as well as with guns. A great anime but it's kinda quick paced. And season 2 was never made. -_- Oh well, the ending to season 1 seemed like it would make a good ending to the anime.
Blood+: Currently #3 on my top 5. The dubs on this one started off pretty bad but I got used to it. :D Another fast paced anime about a girl who has to cooperate with a group of people trying to kill monsters, which she later finds out that she is also one of these monsters. A very good anime, it's probably the second most violent anime I've seen. But it's not all violence, there are a lot of other things going on.
I never used to watch animes... ^^