Duel Academy
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Duel Academy Log in

Get your game on!


SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)

power_settings_newLogin to reply
+15
LegendaryFrost
Johan
bakura normal
Kaito
Bubbles
The_Nameless
FenixFX
Zane Truesdale
PhantomX
Dex
ALu
LòKóS
Phoenix King
FSG
Anzo
19 posters

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptySOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Fri Jan 04, 2013 10:14 am

more_horiz
First topic message reminder :

Rules:
- It has to be your work.
- Discussion and CNC aren't allowed.
- You can only enter the competition with 1 artwork per week.
- You can't vote for yourself.
- Once you submit an artwork, you're not allowed to change it.
- For any question, you PM me, you don't post here.
- You post your entry of the week in this topic.

How are we going to vote:
- We won't be using a poll, instead we'll be using a ?/5 ratio instead. There will be several enteritis per week, you can ?/5 for each of them, and the winner artwork is the one with most points of all.

When does the competition start, and when it ends:
-It starts on Friday, voting starts at Monday, ends on Thursday.


(Everyone will be using the same render, everything else is up to the artists)
Render: https://i.imgur.com/Dvt93.png

Start now.


Edward:
SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 2hwipv8

[PK] Phoenix King
SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 Untitled_1_by_scorpionking234-d5qemg5

ALuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 BrNsY

LOKOS
SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 Heart_by_lokos1-d5qiarp

Staxx
SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 Entry

Shane
SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 Sotw_by_otakucyrus-d5qk7bd

Anzo
SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 M9vGr


Last edited by Anzo on Thu Jan 10, 2013 4:52 pm; edited 3 times in total

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 12:24 pm

more_horiz
Edward wrote:
Okay let's get pro.

PK - 0.5/5
Reason: The whole tag is a big mess, colours don't match the render at all, there's no depth nor flow. My eyes don't know ehere to look at.

Aluu - 1.5/5
Reason: While your right side is nice, the left side is way too empty and dark. Flow is kind of tricky and the overall depth could use some work and would look nice. The render looks worn-out and the overall tag is lacking someidkwhat.

LOKOS - 0.5/5
Reason: Messy and plain. The lighting is off, should be more realistic considering your bg. Those lines behind her are random and distracting.

Staxx - 1.5/5
Reason: It's way too simple not to be boring. I don't really see much going on here. Blurring all the bg like that won't give a feel of depth, just make the composition blurry: like the floor where she should be standing, that shouldn't have been blurried. The render is like not in the sig. I don't see much work in lighting neither, and same as aluu you guys use way too much something and end up killing the quality of the render.

Shane/Dex - 3.5/5
Reason: Kind of having a hard time understanding the composition of the tag. I like the atmosphere but the render seems a tad bit off. Lighting could use some work, effects are nice.

Anzo - 3/5
Reason: The other tag was much more of a kickass, this one is a little more boring. Maybe magenta would be nicer as main colour but that's your choice. Can't say you did a bad job, all the basic reqs are filled. Only thing that's not working is the lighting, it is way too strong for such a render kinda bothers me in the face of her.


Half points ain't acceptable, for instance if you posted 1.5 it'll be cosidered as 1.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 4:30 pm

more_horiz
Anzo, the only person who rounds down at 5 .

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 6:29 pm

more_horiz
that made me lol

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 6:38 pm

more_horiz
Not following ò_ó

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 6:39 pm

more_horiz
Well traditionally once you get to .5 you round up. So 3.5 (and upwards) would go to 4 not 3.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 6:41 pm

more_horiz
I see, i see. I guess i'm that badass then. SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 1151057309

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 6:43 pm

more_horiz
Nope, you just don't want dex to get that extra vote over you because you're too bad to beat him SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 1151057309

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 6:44 pm

more_horiz
SSHHHSSSSSSSS

People doesn't know that yet SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 2723552638

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 8:22 pm

more_horiz
clearly i'm coming in 2nd place

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 8:30 pm

more_horiz
what's wrong with the polls for voting?

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 8:31 pm

more_horiz
It doesn't help to spam. ò_ó

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 8:32 pm

more_horiz
Not trying to help.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 8:33 pm

more_horiz
You got it wrong, you asked whats wrong with voting in polls, i said it doesn't help to spam, not as if you're not helping to spam.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 9:05 pm

more_horiz
with polls we wont know if everyone that entered voted.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 9:10 pm

more_horiz
+ it's fun this way SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 2184694589

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 9:22 pm

more_horiz
Ed - 3.5/5
Phoenix - 2/5
Alu - 3/5
LOKOS - 3/5
Staxx - 5/5
Shane - 2/5
Anzo - 2/5

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 9:30 pm

more_horiz
Ed: 4/5 - You never fail to amaze me o.o
[PK]: 1/5 - Uh... Yea...
Alu: 3/5 - It's good... but... I just don't see it as top notch, I don't really like the lighting
Lokos: 1/5 - ... Messy, bad text, "Eh"ish effects.
Staxx: 3/5 - Nice but not amazing. Doesn't have that "wow" effect.
Shane: 4/5 - What can I say mate, you're one of the best for sure.
Anzo: 3/5 - What can I say, it's good, but not perfect and I don't really like that text a lot.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 11:16 pm

more_horiz
None of ya'll tried to smudge le hoe. You really dunno watcha missed.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Mon Jan 07, 2013 11:35 pm

more_horiz
Anzo make a poll with 2 votes out of all the options (except it's only 2 participants) next time. So much better + less complicated to count in the end.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Tue Jan 08, 2013 12:13 am

more_horiz
The_Nameless wrote:
Anzo make a poll with 2 votes out of all the options (except it's only 2 participants) next time. So much better + less complicated to count in the end.


f*ck, read the whole topic. Somebody already pointed that out.

It's not better because nobody can keep track of the votes.

If somebody really wanted to win they could just make 15 different accounts. Then get 15 free votes. Then they can use the same accounts and do it again next week.

I blame Anzo for the complicated voting system. Oh Shit

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Tue Jan 08, 2013 4:58 am

more_horiz
Maybe it should be like it was in BC - you vote for your top 3, 1st gets 3 points, 2nd - 2 and last one gets 1 point. You will still have to count a lot but it will also make voting easier as you don't have to vote for every single participant.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Tue Jan 08, 2013 3:17 pm

more_horiz
Dunno why complicating it, i'll be the guy to count it. lol

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Tue Jan 08, 2013 3:40 pm

more_horiz
Anzo wrote:
Dunno why complicating it, i'll be the guy to count it. lol


yeah let anzo count so he can chet like he did in DC SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 3785705527

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Tue Jan 08, 2013 9:31 pm

more_horiz
Dunno what you talking about but kay SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 3785705527

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Tue Jan 08, 2013 9:34 pm

more_horiz
make next style free style ok, idc the style, just let us choose our own renders

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Tue Jan 08, 2013 9:35 pm

more_horiz
Will think about it SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 2184694589

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Tue Jan 08, 2013 11:51 pm

more_horiz
[PK] Phoenix King wrote:
make next style free style ok, idc the style, just let us choose our own renders


Anzo wrote:
Will think about it SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 2184694589


please dont

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Tue Jan 08, 2013 11:53 pm

more_horiz
Yeah, freestyle get's boring after awhile. Especially when I'm so picky with renders.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Wed Jan 09, 2013 1:32 am

more_horiz
Damn, I don't mean it like that, but Anzo always sucks at picking renders, that all I'm saying.

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)Wed Jan 09, 2013 5:35 am

more_horiz
Anzo wrote:
Dunno what you talking about but kay SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 3785705527


twa vs da
twa was up but yu dindt update and said we were taking to long and decided for da have the win by CHETTT!!!!!!!!!

descriptionSOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!) - Page 2 EmptyRe: SOTW#6: Specific Render Style (Results!)

more_horiz
privacy_tip Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
power_settings_newLogin to reply